The legacy carriers’ low costs – Lufthansa’s Eurowings, Air France-KLM’s Transavia, IAG’s Vueling: foreign bases, long-haul challenges
Western Europe has three airline groups based around traditional legacy carriers. IAG, which includes British Airways, Iberia and more recently Aer Lingus; Air France / KLM, which also includes HOP!, KLM Cityhopper and Martinair; and Lufthansa Group, which embraces not only Lufthansa, but also Austrian Airlines and SWISS. However, all three groups also have lurking within them, a low-cost subsidiary, namely Vueling, Transavia and Eurowings respectively. This week anna.aero takes a closer look at these three carriers and where they are growing fastest this summer.
Vueling: Big in Barcelona, growing in Amsterdam, London and Paris
Vueling was launched back in July 2004 by Spanish entrepreneurs, and quickly attracted the attention of Iberia who were 20% shareholders in a low-cost rival called clickair, which began operations in October 2006. In 2008 it was announced that the two carriers would merge, which was completed in the summer of 2009 and the Vueling brand name was retained. With Iberia a major shareholder in Vueling, it was not surprising that IAG was interested in the LCC joining the group. This happened in early 2013. Vueling remains an independent carrier within IAG. Other key points:
- Vueling operates a pan-European network with its main base in Barcelona. It also has bases in Belgium, France and Italy.
- According to OAG Schedules Analyser data Vueling offered just under 31 million seats across its network in 2015.
- As of February 2016 its fleet comprises 102 A320-series aircraft with an estimated average age of 6.8 years, according to ch-aviation.
Vueling’s main base at Barcelona is almost four times as big as its next biggest airport, Rome Fiumicino. The airline’s top six airport are all reporting modest growth of between 2% and 9% this August, but three of the airline’s top 15 airports will see year-on-year growth of more than 30% in August. Paris CDG (+75%) leads the way, followed by London Gatwick (+61%) and Amsterdam (+48%). Vueling also operates from London Heathrow (to A Coruña and Barcelona) and will launch its first three routes from London Luton this summer, to Amsterdam, Barcelona and Zurich. Seven of Vueling’s top 10 airports are in Spain.
Transavia: New Munich base coming in March with 18 routes
KLM’s early involvement in LCCs included the London Stansted-based buzz operation (which had evolved out of KLM UK and before that Air UK), and Basiq Air. Transavia started out back in the ‘60s as a charter carrier but then began operating seat-only services, becoming a hybrid carrier. In recent years the carrier has become focussed more on scheduled services and set up a French joint venture with Air France in May 2007. Other key points:
- The Dutch part of Transavia operates under the IATA code of “HV” while the French part has the IATA code “TO”. Having operated under the transavia.com brand for several years, last year the airline name was changed back to Transavia.
- According to Air France’s most recent financial results, Transavia carried 10.81 million passengers (up 9.1%) in 2015 at a load factor of 89.9% and lost €35 million. Revenue per passenger was €102. The fleet comprised 53 aircraft at the end of 2015; 45 737-800s and eight -700s.
- This year the airline is planning to grow ASKs by 15% with further growth in France and a new four-aircraft base opening in Munich in March.
- Transavia’s French-based operation will offer 70 routes this summer; 45 from Paris Orly, 14 from Lyon, 10 from Nantes and a Portuguese domestic route between Porto and Funchal. This is basically the same as last summer, though some routes have been added and some have been dropped.
- Transavia’s Dutch-based operation will offer around 120 routes this summer; almost 60 from Amsterdam, 23 from Eindhoven, 17 from Rotterdam and 18 from its newest base in Munich.
Nearly all of Transavia’s main airports are showing significant growth during the key peak period of August. However, this has mostly been achieved at existing airports by increasing frequencies on existing routes rather than significant network expansion, though Eindhoven’s network has grown from 17 to 23 destinations. Three Portuguese airports rank among the airline’s top 10, with the new Munich base immediately making the southern German airport the LCC’s fourth biggest.
Eurowings: Vienna is first non-German base, long-haul plans evolving
This is complicated. Lufthansa’s involvement in the LCC market started with the creation of Germanwings in 2002. Germanwings was a subsidiary of Eurowings (which was formed in 1993 by a merger between NFD and RFG, two regional airlines), in which Lufthansa took a 25% stake in 2001. Eurowings had a mixed fleet of regional jets and Airbus A320-series aircraft. The latter were used for low-cost operations from a variety of German bases, while the former continued to operate flights for Lufthansa Regional. Lufthansa took complete control of Eurowings in 2011. Lufthansa’s decision that all non-Frankfurt and non-Munich routes should be transferred to Germanwings in 2014 meant that all the Eurowings operated services were now branded as Germanwings flights. In 2015 Lufthansa revealed that Eurowings would become the new name for all Lufthansa’s low-cost operations, including long-haul flights from Cologne Bonn and for based operations outside of Germany. Although only one brand now exists (Eurowings) flights are still operated using Germanwings’s IATA code of 4U as well as Eurowings’s code of EW. Eventually all flights will operate under the EW code. Got it? Other key points:
- Germanwings’s first base was at Cologne Bonn (in October 2002), followed by Stuttgart (September 2003), Berlin (June 2005), Hamburg (November 2005), Dortmund (June 2007) and Hannover (April 2010). When Lufthansa decided to transfer all routes, other than those serving its main hubs at Frankfurt and Munich, to Germanwings/Eurowings, Düsseldorf became a base in 2014.
- Eurowings’s first non-German base opened in Vienna last November with service to three destinations. A further eight destinations will start this summer, some of which are transfers from Germanwings.
- Lufthansa did not split out Eurowings passenger numbers separately from those of Lufthansa in 2015, but will be doing so in 2016. In January 2016 Eurowings carried 1.01 million passengers (+9.1%) at a load factor of 72.1% (up 6.7 percentage points). This was split between short-haul (954,000 passengers at a load factor of 64.1%) and long-haul (52,000 passengers at a load factor of 95.7%).
- According to OAG Schedules Analyser data Eurowings/Germanwings offered 22.4 million seats across its network in 2015.
- As of February 2016, the combined Eurowings/Germanwings fleet comprises 88 aircraft; 70 A320-series aircraft, 16 CRJ 900s, and two widebody aircraft used for the long-haul operations, according to ch-aviation.
Eurowings’s top five airports are all in Germany, though only two other German airports make the top 15. The new Vienna base makes the Austrian airport the fastest-growing among the top 15 (+63%), well ahead of Palma de Mallorca and Milan Malpensa (both +29%). Among airports ranked 16th to 25th there is impressive peak summer growth at Prague (37%), Nuremberg (36%), London Stansted (33%) and Stockholm Arlanda (31%).
Interesting times ahead for all three LCCs
Each of these carriers clearly has an evolving and strategic role to play within the larger airline groups to which they belong. Vueling’s growth in the UK and at major European hubs will be studied closely, while Transavia’s move into the German market could be considered brave. A previous move to set up a base in Denmark at Copenhagen, to take advantage of the collapse of Sterling in late 2008, was relatively short-lived. Meanwhile Eurowings is exploring non-German bases and long-haul flying while still sorting out the transfer of all operations to a single entity. Interesting times indeed.